Actually... it's the Creed discussion list... and since Scott's voice is a pretty important part of Creed... how is this NOT the right place to be talking about his voice? I don't know how long you've been here, but this is something that some of the list members have been theorizing on for some time now. Creed had to postpone shows last tour due to Scott's voice, and a lot of people here have been expecting postponed dates right about this time. It's a widespread opinion on this list that Scott Stapp doesn't take proper care of his voice... that doesn't make the people who hold that opinion not fans. If Tremonti only practiced right before a show, so he didn't build up calluses, so his hands got sore pretty quickly after he began playing in a show... that wouldn't make me less a fan, and wouldn't mean I didn't like the band anymore - it would just mean that fans would be disappointed because his performance level would drop as soon as his fingertips started hurting and the muscles in his hands got tired. Make sense? I'm sure you'll get some more 'enlightening' responses from other list members regarding why this IS the list to discuss Stapp's voice, so I'll just leave it at that.